Health Care Reform: A Practical Path to Affordable Coverage

Health care should be a top priority for the incoming 120th Congress, which has recently announced priorities. Sweeping health care reform likely won’t happen, mainly because any legislation is likely to be vetoed. Much could be accomplished administratively, if executive departments are open to incremental changes.

Health care affects everyone, but not everyone experiences the system in the same way. Some Americans receive insurance through their employers. Others buy individual policies, are self-employed, rely on Medicare or Medicaid, receive veterans’ or military health benefits, or have no insurance.

Person in a wheelchair in a carpeted hallway of a care facility

Citizens may never have enrolled in Medicare or Medicaid, but they still have a stake in how those programs work. They pay taxes, support family members who rely on public programs, and experience the same rising health care costs that affect everyone else.

According to the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2025 report, employer-sponsored insurance remains the largest source of coverage, reaching 53.5 percent of the population. Medicare covers 20.1 percent, Medicaid 17.1 percent, and individually purchased insurance 10.5 percent. Veterans and military health programs cover additional populations. Approximately 26.7 million Americans went the entire year without health insurance.

These categories overlap, but they show the many ways Americans obtain health care coverage.

We also need to clear up a misconception about Medicare for All. Publicly financed health care isn’t necessarily socialized medicine. The government doesn’t own most hospitals or employ most doctors who treat Medicare patients. Medicare pays independent physicians, private hospitals, clinics, laboratories, and other health care providers for the services they deliver. Medicaid also relies heavily on private and community-based providers, alongside public facilities.

In other words, government financing and private health care delivery already coexist. Expanding coverage doesn’t automatically mean eliminating private hospitals, independent doctors, or the health care businesses that serve patients.

There is a distinction between preserving private health care delivery and preserving the existing insurance business model. Some Medicare for All proposals would replace much of the private insurance market for covered services. Insurance companies could lose some of their current business, although other models could retain them in administrative, supplemental, or other roles. Hospitals and physicians would continue delivering care, but payment arrangements and reimbursement rates could change.

The overall goal should be affordable, accessible health care, not winning an ideological argument about whether to finance it through socialism vs. capitalism. Rather than making the debate about government versus the private sector, Democrats can start with common-sense objectives that people across the political spectrum can recognize:

  • Lower prescription drug prices and out-of-pocket medication costs. The current administration is already doing this.
  • Reduce insurance premiums, deductibles, and unexpected medical bills. Many states, like Colorado, have approved “No Surprises” legislation. Premiums and deductibles are the sticking points.
  • Protect rural hospitals and expand community health centers. The “Big Beautiful Bill” provided for some assistance.
  • Improve access to primary care, mental health services, and addiction treatment.
  • Make health insurance more portable so people don’t risk losing coverage when they change jobs. Employers may still provide one plan for their workers, but the aggregate premium may be lower if employees assume part of the premium payment. Under Medicare, recipients pay around $200 per month.
  • Simplify the paperwork and administrative costs that burden patients, providers, and employers. I’ve seen my health insurance provider do this to better manage care and gather patient feedback to improve service delivery.
  • Thanks to Obamacare, people with preexisting conditions are still covered under most plans, as are dependents under 26. Medicare offers Medigap insurance to cover gaps. Medicare for All would likely include supplemental coverage policies.

I believe in an incremental approach. We don’t have to settle every argument about Medicare for All, single-payer insurance, or the role of private companies before we begin improving the system. We can build on existing programs, identify what works, address what doesn’t, and expand access as we go.

Unless you study Medicare and Medicaid—or rely on one yourself—you may not realize Medicare already offers a model that combines public financing with private insurance.

The Clinton administration and Congress established Medicare Part C through the bipartisan Balanced Budget Act of 1997. Originally called Medicare+Choice, it allowed beneficiaries to receive their Medicare benefits through private insurance plans rather than traditional fee-for-service Medicare. The program began in 1999 and was renamed Medicare Advantage in 2003.

Under Part C, Medicare pays approved private insurance companies a fixed monthly amount for each enrollee. The insurers assume financial risk for providing covered care. Most plans offer additional benefits, such as dental and vision coverage, along with copayments and annual out-of-pocket limits.

This isn’t socialized medicine. The government finances and regulates coverage, but private insurance companies administer the plans, while hospitals, physicians, and other health care providers deliver care.

Why not consider using this existing public-private model as a starting point for expanding affordable health coverage? Advantage plans also offer “dual coverage” for those on Medicaid and Medicare. Advantage plans offer Medicare for All. A universal system could borrow features of Medicare Advantage, extending access to regulated private plans and comprehensive benefits beyond today’s Medicare population.

We don’t have to settle the entire Medicare for All debate before making meaningful progress. We can start with what already works, address what doesn’t, and build toward affordable, accessible health care for everyone.

People with employer-sponsored insurance shouldn’t feel that universal health care means their doctors, hospitals, or insurance choices will automatically disappear. Medicare beneficiaries shouldn’t have to defend a system that works well enough for them. Veterans shouldn’t worry about losing specialized care. Small-business owners shouldn’t have to choose between providing health benefits and keeping their businesses afloat. People without insurance shouldn’t have to wait until a medical emergency to receive care.

Finding common threads starts by recognizing that Americans don’t have to agree on the ultimate design of the health care system to agree that getting sick shouldn’t threaten their financial security.

My Experience with the Affordable Care Act

I’ve had health insurance since my first “real job” in Gillette, Wyoming back when Sen. Ted Kennedy was touting universal health care and had Richard Nixon not screwed up with Watergate, would have joined forces with Kennedy and we wouldn’t be having this Obamacare fight today.

Nonetheless, back in 2010, I received a letter from my insurance carrier – Kaiser Permanente – that since I had coverage before ACA went into effect, my policy was “grandfathered” and could keep it or change it with no repercussions from any “pre-existing conditions” that I had or may develop in the future.

I just heard several thousand Kaiser Permanente policy holders got their pink slips that their coverage doesn’t meet the minimum requirements of ACA? What kind of coverage is that? Like a barbecue grill warranty at Walmart? The ACA naysayers have been finding stories about us self employed people who have had their policies handled. What’s the big deal? For the past 10 years, my plan has been cancelled like clockwork on December 31st. If I want to reup, the policies are similar, but the price has always gone up. I’ve had to increase my deductible over the years to keep a reasonable price. ACA or not, my carrier will be cancelling my policy December 14, 2014 as usual and every year after. But at least they can’t kick me out for some medical reason.

When ACA was in its infancy, my premium price dropped, not a lot, but a few bucks. Meanwhile, there was no national health care exchange, but many private ones out there. Since I couldn’t be denied coverage, I did shop around on a private exchange and ended up finding a less expensive plan that had a little better coverage from my existing carrier – it’s a medium deductible co-pay plan – and the plan I’ve had for three years or so. Over the past couple years, my prescription prices dropped to grocery store levels ($5 or buy 2 get one free).

Private healthcare exchanges

On October 1, I signed up with the Colorado healthcare exchange. On day one, I had a few problems getting my account set up – I was bumped off the site a few times, timed out a few times, but eventually was able to get a good connection. After all that and to my surprise, there were no plans offered with coverage even close to what I purchased on the private market.  They all had very high deductibles and premiums that were nearly double what I was currently paying. Apparently, the income-based tax credits would lower the costs dramatically, but the coverage is still terrible, at best. The Connect for Colorado Health support has been great. I’ve been called a couple times to help me get finally through the process which has been goo.

I imagine it has something to do with the actuarial tables that show that low-income people tend to have bigger health problems than the general population, which is why all sorts of people are necessary in the risk pool. These “low-end” policies end up costing less with the tax credits applied. If you’ve been denied coverage all these years, this type of policy is probably considered “gold”. The premiums are likely based on the probability that mostly uninsured, ergo unhealthy, and low income folks will be the ones who apply. I also surmise that places like Wyoming that chose to opt out of the Medicaid expansion plopped all those “high risk” people into the general risk pool, which was a contributing factor to higher premiums.

The Mississippi experience

Rural areas lack competition

There are dental plans offered, but none from my current dentist, which is one of the publicly-traded dentists, Perfect Teeth. I may switch over to Delta Dental if after comparing my Perfect Teeth discount program, it turns out to be way better. Kaiser doesn’t offer dental coverage.

I looked around on the Kaiser Permanente site for plans and found one that had a lower deductible than I currently have and the cost was a third less and called about it and found out that I could switch over, but it would expire for me at the end of 2013 and if i kept it, the price would jump up to the Colorado Health Exchange price, which was over double what I currently spend.

The Kaiser Permanente member service representative on the phone said that they figure out ACA tax credit eligibility too. They have an entire staff designated to Medicaid and Medicare paperwork and I would imagine is very good at working through each state to figure out any ACA red tape.

The upshot?

In my case:

– ACA saves me a few bucks on premiums and lots of bucks on prescriptions

– ACA gives me peace of mind about the future because my insurance won’t get cancelled

– ACA covers a whole bunch of people who won’t be using the emergency room staff as their primary care physicians which, in the long, run will keep my premiums lower by putting their risk in their own pool and not mine.

ACA has caught on and will only improve as more people previously uninsured participate. I think that the national health care exchange is good if you don’t already have coverage and income eligible for tax credits. I heard the dead-beat states that let the federal government run their exchanges are missing the boat and the can-do states that tailored their own are having pretty good success.

State run exchanges more successful

Most people have coverage and If you do, I suggest sticking with learning information from your carrier and not mess around with the national exchange. If you’re in the market or curious as to what choices are out there, also check out the private health care exchanges. You’ll be asked for the same personal information as the Obamacare website asks. Like all other internet commerce, be careful!