Immigration reform should be one issue where Democrats and Republicans can find common ground. I have a particular interest, since in 1991, I was detained at gunpoint for being an undocumented worker in Mexico. I reported to the Mexican Embassy in Denver and was approved for the correct visa.
The sharp decline in unauthorized border encounters was a good thing. A country has a responsibility to know who enters, enforce its laws, and maintain an orderly immigration process. Stronger border security addressed a legitimate public concern.
Securing the border and reforming immigration are two different challenges. We need to do both.
Republicans aren’t opposed to immigration. Many support legal immigration, provided people follow an established process. That’s a reasonable starting point for a bipartisan discussion.
Ronald Reagan understood that distinction. In 1986, he signed the bipartisan Immigration Reform and Control Act. The legislation strengthened border enforcement, penalized employers who knowingly hired undocumented workers, and provided legal status to approximately 2.7 million people who met its requirements.
It recognized a practical reality that millions of people had established lives in America. They worked, raised families, paid taxes, and contributed to their communities. Rather than attempt to remove everyone, Congress created an opportunity for eligible people to earn legal status and eventually become citizens.
A pathway to citizenship isn’t a bad thing. People who have lived here for years, worked, paid taxes, and contributed to their communities deserve consideration for an earned pathway. Background checks, tax compliance, and other reasonable requirements should be part of the process.
Legalizing an immigrant’s status means finding a way to bring people into compliance. Finding them all, arresting them all, and deporting them all is expensive, disruptive, and daunting.
ICE needs accountability, not abolition.
Immigration enforcement has a legitimate purpose. ICE has an important role in enforcing federal immigration laws. Abolishing or defunding the agency isn’t the answer.
The way ICE carries out that mission matters.
Broad enforcement sweeps, questionable arrests, detention conditions, use-of-force incidents, and concerns about due process have raised legitimate questions about the administration’s tactics.
The answer isn’t to eliminate immigration enforcement. It’s to establish reasonable priorities, respect due process, identify officers, require appropriate training and accountability, and concentrate resources on genuine public safety concerns.
The distinction is important. Enforcing immigration laws and treating people fairly aren’t mutually exclusive.
What can the 120th Congress actually do?
Here’s where the legislative process gets complicated.
The Constitution gives Congress broad authority over immigration. Courts have described this as plenary power. Congress writes the laws governing who may enter the country, who may remain, and under what conditions.
Congress doesn’t manage ICE’s daily operations.
Over the years, Congress has delegated substantial authority to the Department of Homeland Security and its agencies. The executive branch determines enforcement priorities, including whom to arrest, detain, and deport. It also establishes operational policies governing raids, detention practices, and enforcement tactics.
The new Congress cannot tell ICE agents to change their procedures through a committee vote. It does have several tools.
Investigate and provide oversight.
With Democrats controlling both chambers, congressional committees can hold hearings, subpoena administration officials, demand records, investigate detention conditions, and examine allegations of excessive force or due process violations.
They can also demand a detailed accounting of how ICE spends its money.
Oversight won’t immediately change enforcement policies, but public hearings and investigations can expose abuses and create pressure for administrative changes.
Put conditions on future funding.
Congress controls federal appropriations. It can attach restrictions to future annual funding bills, requiring officer identification, body cameras, use-of-force reporting, training standards, and clearer rules governing detention and arrests.
There’s an obstacle.
The 119th Congress approved enormous amounts of additional funding through two reconciliation laws in 2025 and 2026. Together, they provided approximately $261 billion in multi-year funding for DHS, including roughly $113 billion specifically for ICE.
Much of that money remains available through 2029. Cutting the next annual ICE budget won’t automatically recover money Congress has already appropriated.
To rescind or redirect those existing funds, the new Congress would need to pass another law. President Trump could veto it.
Rewrite immigration laws.
Congress can amend the Immigration and Nationality Act to establish clearer enforcement priorities, strengthen due-process protections, establish detention standards, and provide additional resources for immigration courts.
It can also address the legal immigration system itself. Long delays, inadequate staffing, complicated visa requirements, and an overloaded asylum process contribute to the problems Congress needs to solve.
The Senate also has a role in confirming senior agency leadership. It can scrutinize future nominees and block candidates who don’t meet its expectations. That gives senators some leverage, although it doesn’t give them direct control over ICE operations.
Find bipartisan legislation.
This may be the most productive approach.
The bipartisan Dignity Act, for example, offers a starting point for discussions about combining border security, legal immigration reform, and a pathway to legal status for eligible immigrants.
Congress could also revisit legislation protecting Dreamers, people brought to the United States as children, many of whom have grown up here and know no other home.
There is no shortage of proposals. The challenge is finding enough common ground to pass them.
The political reality
The incoming 120th Congress will have a Democratic majority in both chambers, but President Trump remains in the White House.
Major immigration legislation will need 60 votes in the Senate to overcome a filibuster, followed by the president’s signature. A presidential veto would require two-thirds of both chambers to override.

Trump recently acknowledged that his deportation approach may have been too aggressive and suggested he might work with Democrats. On the other hand, his administration has said its enforcement policies haven’t changed. An opening for negotiations isn’t the same as an agreement.
Democrats should resist turning immigration into another partisan contest over who can sound tougher or more compassionate.
They should work with Republicans on secure borders, effective enforcement, a functioning legal immigration system, and an earned pathway for people who have established lives here.
Secure borders, enforceable laws, legal immigration, and humane treatment aren’t mutually exclusive.
The 120th Congress has the constitutional authority to reshape immigration law. Whether it has the political will to do so is another question.
Fixing immigration will require a willingness to compromise, which Washington has lacked.
