Two Blue Waves, 52 Years Apart: What Can the 120th Congress Learn From 1974?

Watergate brought Democrats a sweeping victory in 1974. The 2026 midterms delivered another Blue Wave. The question now is what Democrats will do with their new majority.

Watergate brought Democrats a sweeping victory in 1974. The 2026 midterms delivered another Blue Wave. The question now is what Democrats will do with their new majority.

A historical parallel is emerging from the 2026 midterm elections. I’ve been watching the political pundits compare this year’s Democratic victories to the Blue Wave of 1974.

Vintage Richard M. Nixon inauguration button featuring his portrait, the American flag, and text reading “Inauguration Day Jan. 20th, 1973” and “37th President.”

The comparison makes sense.

In 1974, Democrats gained a net 43 seats in the House and expanded their Senate majority. The election followed the Watergate scandal, Richard Nixon’s resignation, and Gerald Ford’s controversial pardon of his predecessor. The newcomers became known as the “Watergate Babies.”

In 2026, Democrats did something even more consequential: they captured both the House and Senate, flipping at least seven Senate seats and more than two dozen House districts. The victories represented a sweeping rejection of the Trump administration.

The two elections share more than impressive Democratic gains. Both followed periods of public disillusionment with the party controlling the White House.

In 1974, voters were angry about Watergate, the unpopular Vietnam War, rising inflation, and the energy crisis. In 2026, concerns about government corruption, the war with Iran, and the cost of living again helped drive voters away from the party in power.

The circumstances aren’t identical. Nixon had resigned before the 1974 election. Trump remains president. In both midterm election cycles, voters expressed a broader concern.

I’ll point out three similarities from 1974 that the incoming 120th Congress will face beginning January 3, 2027.

Government accountability: The unfinished Watergate lesson

Watergate exposed a system in which campaign money, political influence, and presidential power became intertwined.

Black-and-white cartoon of two men sitting at a restaurant table beneath a “Victory!” banner, with one holding wine and the other drinking Diet Coke while a worker sweeps the empty room.

Nixon’s Committee to Re-Elect the President, known as CREEP, collected enormous sums, including illegal contributions. Campaign operatives participated in the Democratic Headquarters break-in at the Watergate Hotel. The Nixon administration attempted to conceal its involvement. Nixon ultimately resigned rather than face impeachment proceedings.

Nixon’s resignation was only part of the story.

The chain of events began ten months earlier.

In October 1973, Vice President Spiro Agnew resigned amid a federal investigation into allegations that he had accepted kickbacks while serving as Baltimore County executive, governor of Maryland, and vice president. As part of a plea agreement, he pleaded no contest to a federal charge of failing to report income on his tax returns.

Two days after Agnew resigned, Nixon nominated House Minority Leader Gerald Ford to replace him. Congress confirmed Ford, and he became vice president on December 6, 1973.

By the summer of 1974, the Watergate scandal had brought Nixon to the brink of impeachment. The House Judiciary Committee approved three articles of impeachment in late July. Nixon ultimately resigned on August 9, before the full House could vote on them.

A month later, Ford pardoned Nixon for any federal crimes he might have committed while president. The pardon sparked widespread criticism. Many Americans suspected a backroom deal and felt Washington’s political establishment had protected one of its own. The pardon sparked widespread criticism. Many Americans suspected a backroom deal and felt Washington’s political establishment had protected one of its own.

The Watergate midterm election brought a new generation of lawmakers to Washington determined to change the rules. Congress strengthened campaign finance laws, established the Federal Election Commission, and investigated abuses by government agencies. Subsequent legislation strengthened government transparency and ethics requirements.

The 2026 election raises familiar questions about conflicts of interest, personal enrichment, and whether public office is being used to benefit political insiders.

An Associated Press post-election poll found that voters viewed Trump as more focused on his personal fortune than their needs. Roughly seven in ten also believed Congress wasn’t doing enough to provide checks and balances on the president.

The incoming Congress has an opportunity to restore public confidence through meaningful oversight, financial disclosure, stronger conflict-of-interest protections, and independent government watchdogs.

Investigating past wrongdoing is important. Establishing rules that prevent it from happening again is even more important.

Healthcare reform: A missed opportunity from 1974

Here’s an interesting piece of history that deserves another look.

In 1974, President Richard Nixon and Senator Ted Kennedy were both pursuing national health insurance reform. They had very different ideas about how to accomplish it, but both recognized that the existing system left too many Americans without adequate coverage.

Nixon proposed a comprehensive insurance plan built largely around employer-provided private insurance, with government assistance for people who couldn’t obtain coverage through work.

Kennedy, working with Representative Wilbur Mills, advocated a more expansive national health insurance system financed through payroll taxes and general revenues.

Their representatives explored a possible compromise, but the two sides never reached an agreement. Watergate eventually consumed the Nixon administration, and the opportunity disappeared.

More than 50 years later, Americans are still struggling with healthcare costs, insurance premiums, prescription drug prices, and medical debt.

The 2027 Congress doesn’t have to begin by debating Medicare for All versus private insurance. It can start with areas where there is room for agreement: prescription drug costs, hospital pricing, insurance company practices, and out-of-pocket expenses.

The lesson from 1974 is that healthcare reform shouldn’t become another casualty of partisan politics. Nixon and Kennedy came closer to an agreement than many people remember. Perhaps today’s Congress can find common ground.

Environmental protection: From the EPA to the data center boom

Another surprising historical connection is environmental protection.

Richard Nixon, hardly remembered today as an environmental champion, proposed creating the Environmental Protection Agency in 1970. Congress approved his plan to consolidate federal environmental responsibilities under one agency.

The EPA began operating in December 1970. The same period produced major environmental legislation, including the Clean Air Act amendments and the Clean Water Act.

Across party lines, there was broad recognition that protecting public health and natural resources required a national response.

The environmental challenges facing the 2027 Congress look different, but the need for government oversight hasn’t disappeared.

Consider the rapid expansion of data centers to support artificial intelligence and cloud computing.

These facilities require enormous amounts of electricity and, in many cases, water for cooling. Their construction can place substantial demands on local utilities and water supplies. Communities ask who pays for the infrastructure, whether electricity rates will rise, and what happens to local water resources.

State and local governments still make most decisions about land use, water allocation, and utility rates. Congress can’t dictate where every data center gets built.

Washington has an important role.

The incoming Congress could establish consistent requirements for disclosing electricity and water consumption, strengthen environmental reporting, encourage water recycling and efficient cooling, and use federal incentives to ensure developers account for the infrastructure costs their projects create.

The objective shouldnshouldn’tstop technological progress. It should ensure the benefits of artificial intelligence don’t come at the expense of the communities hosting the facilities or the households paying the utility bills.

In 1970, the federal government responded to the environmental challenges of its time by creating the EPA. In 2027, Congress needs to consider how existing environmental protections should apply to the challenges of a new technological era.

A Blue Wave: Accomplishment with a range of opportunities

The Watergate Babies entered Congress with a mandate to restore confidence in government. They helped change the rules governing campaign finance, transparency, and public accountability.

The 2026 Blue Wave offers Democrats a similar opportunity.

The 120th Congress could spend the next two years opposing Trump and investigating his administration. It also needs to demonstrate that a Democratic majority can accomplish more than resisting a Republican president.

Government accountability, affordable healthcare, and environmental protection are responsibilities of a government that serves the public.

The 1974 election showed what happens when voters lose confidence in the people running Washington. The 2026 election suggests that the same warning has surfaced again.

The incoming Congress’s real accomplishment will be giving voters a reason to believe in government again.

Democrats’ Path to a Lasting Majority: Common Threads

My mother’s Stitch and Bitch club might have a few lessons for the next Congress.

My mother belonged to a handwork club called the “Stitch and Bitch.” The name pretty much said it all. Women gathered around their handiwork, shared stories, exchanged opinions and, I imagine, solved a few of the world’s problems along the way.

I’ve been thinking about that club while watching the political aftermath of the 2026 midterm elections. My mom’s sewing circle picked a theme, and each member gave their interpretation. They disagreed, but accepted each other’s version as long as it fit the underlying theme.

It occurred to me that Democrats could learn a lesson from a group of women sitting around a table with needles, thread, and different ideas about what they wanted to make.

If Democrats want to turn the 2026 blue wave into a lasting governing majority, they need a bigger hoop going into the first 100 days of 2027.

To be honest, the new majority won’t be able to do much if President Trump keeps his word and vetoes any legislation that comes to his desk.

Regardless, the November 2026 general election delivered Democrats an opportunity. It didn’t deliver a mandate for a uniformly progressive agenda. The blue wave swept through some traditionally conservative states and districts, bringing along voters who don’t necessarily share the Democratic Party’s most progressive positions.

That’s an important distinction.

Democrats have spent considerable time arguing among themselves about their own members’ political leanings. Pennsylvania Senator John Fetterman, former West Virginia Senator Joe Manchin, and former Arizona Senator Kyrsten Sinema all drew criticism from Democrats when they broke with the party on particular issues.

Their critics treated those disagreements as evidence of political disloyalty. Elected representatives have a responsibility to represent the people who sent them to Washington.

In 2009, incumbent Representative Marilyn Musgrave of Congressional District 4 focused on culture wars and aligned herself with an unpopular president.

Sound familiar? CD 4 is now the home of Lauren Boebert.

A newcomer, Betsy Markey, soundly defeated Musgrave. The Democrats coerced her into voting for Obamacare. Two years later, she lost by 12 points to Republican Corey Gardner. Markey’s loss created a domino effect. In 2014, Gardner upset incumbent Democrat Mark Udall and became an integral member of the so-called “Make America Great Again” coalition.

The moral of the story? A Democrat representing a conservative constituency faces different political realities than a Democrat representing Boulder, Manhattan, or San Francisco.

The incoming Congress will include more Democrats representing places where progressive politics don’t resonate, like South Carolina, Mississippi, and Texas. If party leaders expect those members to vote as though they represent the same constituency, they risk turning an electoral victory into a political liability.

Look what happened in 2026.

Democrats don’t have to abandon their principles or move wholesale to the right. A successful political coalition needs room for different opinions.

The common thread: Getting through life with fewer financial burdens

If Democrats want to govern, they should begin with issues that matter to people regardless of their political affiliation.

They don’t have to agree on every policy detail. They need to identify problems that Americans share and find practical ways to address them.

Over the next few days, I’ll share some ideas on how the new Congressional majority can improve everyday life.

What could Democrats accomplish if they spent less time arguing over ideological purity and more time addressing shared concerns?

Here’s a teaser about six places to start:

  • Bring down prices. Help families manage the cost of groceries, utilities, housing, childcare, and other expenses that eat into their paychecks.
  • Provide less expensive healthcare. Lower prescription drug and insurance costs while protecting access to doctors, hospitals, mental health services, and addiction treatment.
  • Build more entry-level houses. Give younger families a realistic shot at homeownership and make rental housing more affordable for people at every stage of life.
  • Invest in jobs and practical education. Expand trade schools, apprenticeships, community colleges, and workforce training while continuing to support universities and research.
  • Make communities safer. Support effective local law enforcement, police accountability, responsible gun ownership, and practical efforts to reduce violence.
  1. Invest in jobs and practical education. Expand trade schools, apprenticeships, community colleges, and workforce training while continuing to support universities and research.Fix immigration. Secure the border, enforce immigration laws, maintain a workable legal immigration system, and create a fair process for people who have built their lives here.- Keep energy affordable and reliable in the age of AI. Modernize the electric grid, develop dependable energy sources, and address the enormous power and water demands of data centers.

None of these issues belong exclusively to one political party. Democrats don’t have to agree on every solution, but they should be able to find enough common thread to get something done. That’s what creating multiple designs in a bigger embroidery hoop is all about.

Rethinking Immigration: Lessons from the ‘No Kings’ March

Today, I attended the “No Kings” march. The crowd seemed smaller than at previous demonstrations I’ve attended, but the messages on the posters stayed the same. Signs scattered throughout the gathering condemned ICE, challenged its tactics, demanded accountability, and called for the agency’s abolition.

A person taking a selfie at the Boulder Farmers Market, with information booths and a crowd visible in the background. The person wears sunglasses and a cap, and there are colorful market tents set up.

Those signs got me thinking about how we arrived at this moment and whether we’ve learned anything from our history.

Controlling borders and regulating immigration are legitimate government responsibilities. How we carry out those responsibilities matters. An immigration system that separates families, instills fear in communities, and treats people as security threats before considering their individual circumstances deserves more than a budget increase and a political talking point.

It deserves a fundamental rethink.

How We Got Here

Immigration enforcement in the United States didn’t always work the way we know it today.

The U.S. Customs Service dates to 1789, when the federal government needed to collect tariffs and generate revenue. The Immigration Act of 1891 established a centralized federal role in immigration control. The following year, Ellis Island opened as a major immigration inspection station. Congress created the U.S. Border Patrol in 1924 to police land borders between official ports of entry.

In 1933, the government consolidated immigration functions into the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS). In 1940, the agency transferred to the Department of Justice and administered legal immigration and naturalization while enforcing immigration laws and deporting people who violated them.

That arrangement had its shortcomings, but it recognized that immigration involved more than enforcement. People applied for citizenship. Others faced removal proceedings.

Then came September 11, 2001.

A view of a street with a construction fence and debris in the background, showing the remains of a demolished building. A person in a coat stands on the sidewalk, with other buildings and cables visible.

In the aftermath of the terrorist attacks, Congress passed the Homeland Security Act of 2002. The government dismantled the INS and transferred its functions, along with those of the U.S. Customs Service, into the newly established Department of Homeland Security.

By 2003, three agencies had taken shape:

  • U.S. Customs and Immigration Service (CIS), responsible for administering lawful immigration and citizenship applications.
  • Customs and Border Protection (CBP), responsible for border security and enforcement at ports of entry.
  • Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), responsible for interior immigration enforcement, detention, deportation, and certain criminal investigations.

The restructuring reflected a new national security environment, placing immigration enforcement within a department built to protect the country from security threats.

Crossing a border unlawfully is not automatically the same thing as posing a threat to national security. Yet the post-9/11 framework embeds immigration enforcement within a broader security system, where the tools, priorities, and institutional culture emphasize apprehension and removal over the circumstances of individual people.

We should be asking whether that approach serves the country today.

Reagan, IRCA, and a Different Approach

Immigration reform wasn’t always the political third rail it has become.

A blue campaign button featuring the word 'REAGAN' in bold white letters, with the slogan 'Let's make America great again' underneath.

In 1986, President Ronald Reagan signed the Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA). The law provided a path to legal status for approximately 2.7 million undocumented immigrants who met its eligibility requirements, including continuous residence in the United States since January 1, 1982.

Reagan understood that millions of people had already established lives here. They worked, raised families, paid bills, and contributed to their communities. Removing everyone who lacked legal status would have been an enormous undertaking, with consequences extending far beyond the individuals targeted.

IRCA offered a compromise. It combined legalization for eligible immigrants with employer sanctions for hiring unauthorized workers and increased resources for immigration enforcement. The legislation was imperfect, and its enforcement provisions created their own problems. Nevertheless, it demonstrated that a conservative president and a bipartisan Congress could acknowledge an uncomfortable reality: an immigration system that ignores the lives people have built here will never resolve the problem simply by ordering them to leave.

I have a personal reason for thinking about that history.

The Tanaka Farm: A Local Lesson in Immigration Policy

Near Longmont, the history of the Tanaka Brothers Farms offers a revealing local chapter in the complicated relationship between agriculture, immigration, and federal policy.

A weathered white building with a red roof is situated in an open field, surrounded by sparse trees and grass under a partly cloudy sky.

The Tanaka family’s agricultural story stretches back through the experiences of Japanese Americans who built lives and businesses in Colorado, including people whose families endured incarceration during World War II. The family’s farming operation relied on immigrant labor.

IRCA’s employer-sanctions provisions eventually extended to agricultural employers, bringing new compliance obligations to an industry dependent on seasonal labor. By the early 1990s, the Tanaka Brothers Farms operation had entered bankruptcy proceedings.

The timing invites questions about how immigration policy, labor requirements, agricultural economics, and the treatment of farmworkers intersected. It does not, by itself, establish that IRCA caused the farm’s collapse. That history deserves a closer look at the evidence, the decisions, and the people who lived through the consequences.

Three individuals engaged in conversation by a gate outdoors, with a grassy area and a building in the background.

I’m pursuing those questions in a book and documentary project that examines the Tanaka farm and the larger agricultural history of the Boulder-Longmont area, including the Japanese American community, migrant labor, and the forces that shaped who worked the land—and who ultimately benefited from it.

Local history can reveal what national political arguments often obscure. Immigration policy doesn’t exist in a vacuum. It reaches into fields, workplaces, families, and communities, with consequences that can last for generations.

Where Do We Go From Here?

Today’s turnout may have been smaller than I expected. That doesn’t make its message less urgent. Public attention comes and goes, but federal enforcement policies continue to affect people’s lives long after demonstrators return home.

A person wearing a gray beanie holds a cardboard sign that reads 'Melt Ice' at a protest, with other protesters and signs visible in the background.

We need to distinguish between enforcing immigration law and treating enforcement itself as the ultimate goal.

An alternative would preserve legitimate border controls while establishing clear limits on enforcement powers, meaningful independent oversight, due process, and humane treatment. It would create workable legal pathways for people with deep roots here, meet the demand for immigrant labor, and let employers and workers comply with the law without turning entire communities into targets.

We should also ask whether ICE, as currently structured, is the best way to accomplish those objectives. No federal agency deserves immunity from scrutiny because Congress created it, presidents reshaped it, and changing political priorities gave it new missions.

What government builds, government can change.

Reagan’s IRCA compromise reminds us that immigration policy need not be a choice between unrestricted entry and mass deportation. The history of the Tanaka farm reminds us that federal decisions can have consequences far beyond the halls of Congress and the headlines of the day.

The “No Kings” march reminded me that government derives its authority from the people. That principle must mean more than showing up with a sign once or twice a year. It means insisting that government agencies remain accountable to the public they serve.

If our immigration system produces fear without lasting solutions, divides families without addressing the forces that draw people here, and consumes public resources without resolving the problems it was created to solve, then defending the status quo is not responsible governance. It is a refusal to learn.

We can secure our borders without abandoning our humanity. We can enforce laws without treating every undocumented person as a threat. And we can demand accountability without pretending that the only choices are to accept the system as it stands or abolish every form of immigration enforcement.

That work shouldn’t end when the march ends.